Cambridge Citizens Coalition
|
Also read our complementary post on this polling report: “ABC’s Polling Problems: Embold’s 10.11.26 Report” (11.1.26) HERE Behind the headline claiming 64% support for Cambridge's Multifamily Housing Ordinance are substantial demands for changes, significant demographic divisions, and unanswered questions about the survey itself. Only 20% Want to Keep the Ordinance Unchanged. The most revealing finding in the recent Cambridge Multifamily Housing Ordinance poll may not be the widely publicized claim that 64% of respondents support the ordinance. It is that only 20% want to keep the ordinance exactly as it is. Another 32% favor small, targeted changes, while 37% favor broader changes, even if those changes slow the construction of new housing. Ten percent were unsure. Thus, nearly seven in ten respondents favor some degree of change. This does not mean that 69% oppose the ordinance. But it does mean that the 64% support figure cannot reasonably be interpreted as an unqualified endorsement of the ordinance in its present form. See the top image: Only 20% of respondents favored retaining the Multifamily Housing Ordinance unchanged. A combined 69% favored either targeted or broader changes. What Does the 64% Support Figure Actually Measure?The survey reports that 64% support the ordinance, 28% oppose it, and 8% are unsure. But respondents were given a particular description of the ordinance. They were told that it permits residential buildings up to four stories citywide and up to six stories on larger lots for projects providing income-restricted housing. They were not simultaneously informed about the potential demolition of existing housing, displacement of current tenants, removal of mature trees, increased shading, or the effects of substantially larger buildings on neighboring properties. These omissions matter because the question measured responses to the ordinance as described, not necessarily approval of every provision or consequence. There is an important distinction between supporting the general goal of creating more housing and endorsing the specific rules governing how and where housing is built. The Poll reports 64% overall support for the ordinance, but the question does not address several potential consequences of redevelopment. The ABC Polling Questions Framed Their Housing Choices FAR Too Narrowly One question asked respondents to choose between allowing more homes to be built, even if doing so changes the look and feel of residential neighborhoods, and preserving neighborhood look and feel, even if that means fewer new homes. This framing is restrictive. It presents the debate principally as a choice between increasing housing production and protecting neighborhood appearance. But many concerns about the ordinance have little to do with aesthetics. They concern demolition, displacement, affordability, mature trees, neighborhood heat, sunlight, infrastructure, and whether residents retain meaningful opportunities to review development proposals. A resident could favor the construction of additional housing while simultaneously opposing demolition of occupied rental buildings or the removal of large trees. The survey did not allow respondents to express such combinations of preferences in that question. Respondents were asked to choose between more housing and neighborhood look and feel, without explicitly considering displacement, environmental effects, or infrastructure. Age and Housing Status Reveal Major Divisions The detailed cross-tabulations indicate substantial differences in support across age groups and between homeowners and renters. In the age breakdown for ordinance support, the tables report 86% support among respondents ages 18–34, compared with 38% among those aged 65 and older. That is a very large difference. These results suggest that the citywide headline figure combines groups with markedly different attitudes. It is especially important to understand the unweighted sample sizes within each age category before drawing firm conclusions about the magnitude of these differences. The survey reports a pronounced age divide in support for the ordinance. Subgroup results should be interpreted in light of their sample sizes. The survey also shows differences between homeowners and renters. This distinction deserves careful examination because existing renters may face very different risks from redevelopment than renters hoping to find new housing. The renter category does not distinguish between those living in older buildings that might be demolished and those living in new construction, subsidized housing, or other housing arrangements. Nor does the survey directly ask respondents how they would feel if redevelopment involved the loss of their existing home. The poll shows that 36% of respondents owned their homes; 57% rented their homes; and 7% lived with friends or family. But the poll never asked the type of home (condo; duplex; single family house), nor did it ask if respondents were students, post-docs or interns in the area, or even if they hoped to live here five years from now. We have a very large student and post-doc population and this would be important to know. Why Was Household Composition Not Examined? The questionnaire includes categories for age, gender, race or ethnicity, education, homeownership, and presidential voting history. It does not report whether respondents were married, single, living with a partner, raising children, living alone, or part of a multigenerational household. These characteristics may be relevant to housing preferences and experiences of neighborhood change. Marital status need not necessarily be used as a weighting variable. Nevertheless, information about household composition could help explain differences in housing needs and policy priorities. The Poll's Sizable Methodological Limitations: The poll was conducted September 28–October 4, 2026. It reports a weighted sample of 442 respondents and a modeled margin of error of 4.9 percentage points. Those figures provide useful information, but they do not by themselves establish how representative the findings are of Cambridge residents or voters. Who Was Surveyed, and How Were Respondents Recruited? The supplied poll tables do not fully document the recruitment process other than to say that a majority of respondents were those who responded to text messages and the remaining ones responded to social media queries. Were respondents selected through probability sampling, recruited from an online panel, or obtained through another method? What procedures were used to verify residency, avoid duplicate responses, and ensure sufficient representation across neighborhoods? These questions are important because the answers affect the meaning of the survey results. What Role Did Weighting Play? The poll identifies its results as weighted, but the materials provided do not fully explain the weighting procedure. Weighting is commonly used in survey research to correct differences between the sample and the population the researchers intend to represent. It is not inherently problematic. However, the procedures should be transparent. The weighted respondent profile reports that 39% were ages 18–34, 57% were renters, and 44% held graduate degrees. Readers need to know how these proportions were established and whether they reflect the intended target population. Were respondents weighted by age, race, gender, education, homeownership, or previous voting behavior? Which population benchmarks were used? Were any adjustments made to recruitment targets or quotas while the poll was being conducted? If procedures changed during fieldwork, what prompted those changes, and how did they affect the final results? Such adjustments are not necessarily inappropriate, but they warrant explanation. A complete methodological report should include both weighted and unweighted sample distributions, the weighting targets, the range of survey weights, and the effective sample size. Until that information is available, readers cannot independently assess how strongly the results depend on the weighting decisions. 4.9% Margin of Error Does Not Apply to Every Subgroup The reported 4.9-point modeled margin of error refers to the overall sample under the researcher's assumptions. The survey's detailed cross-tabulations divide respondents into smaller groups according to age, gender, race, education, housing status, and other characteristics. The sample sizes for some of these groups may be quite small. Consequently, differences among subgroups should be interpreted cautiously, particularly without the underlying unweighted counts and appropriate uncertainty estimates. A percentage calculated from a small subgroup is not as reliable as the same percentage calculated from a large sample. Does the Sample Represent Cambridge Voters? The survey reports that 80% of respondents voted for Kamala Harris in 2024, 8% for Donald Trump, and 4% for another candidate. Eight percent reported not voting, while 1% reported being ineligible, too young, or unregistered. These figures describe the sample, but their relationship to Cambridge's actual electorate requires further examination. The weighted age profile is particularly important: 39% of respondents were between 18 and 34. Cambridge has a large student and university-affiliated population, including people whose length of residence, voter registration, and participation in municipal elections may differ from those of longer-term residents. This does not make their views less important. It does mean that a poll of residents and a poll of likely municipal voters are not interchangeable. If the results are used to make claims about City Council elections, the distinction deserves explicit acknowledgment. Who Designed the Questionnaire and Analyzed the Results? An additional concern is the relationship between the polling firm and the organizations commissioning the research, the pro-development groups , A Better Cambridge and Abundance Housing. Who wrote the questions? Who selected the alternatives offered to respondents? Who approved the final questionnaire? Who determined the weighting targets? Did Embold Research independently develop the survey instrument, or did the commissioning organizations provide or approve the wording? Who conducted the statistical analysis, and was there any independent review? These are questions about transparency, not accusations of misconduct. Full methodological documentation would allow readers to evaluate the findings more confidently. What the Poll Failed to Ask. This is even more significant than the polling questions and results themselves. Several important issues surrounding the 2025 ordinance were not directly addressed in the questionnaire. The poll did not ask about: the demolition of Existing Homes: Should existing residential buildings be demolished to make way for larger developments? The poll did not ask about site types: Should the city distinguish between construction on vacant land and construction requiring demolition of occupied housing? The poll did not ask: Displacement of Existing Renters How should the city protect tenants whose leases may be terminated or whose homes may be demolished? Would respondents support the same development policies if they knew current residents might lose their housing? The poll did not ask: Loss of Older, Relatively Affordable Housing. Much of Cambridge's older housing provides rental options whose prices may be lower than those in newly constructed market-rate buildings, although this varies by property. The poll did not ask whether preserving existing lower-cost housing should be prioritized alongside adding new housing. The poll did not ask about: Mature Trees and Environmental Damage. Should developers be permitted to remove mature trees to accommodate new buildings? What protections should apply to existing canopy, neighborhood shade, stormwater absorption, and urban heat? The poll did not ask about: Sunlight and Increased Shading. How should the city balance increased building heights against the potential loss of sunlight to neighboring homes, apartments, gardens, and public spaces? The poll did not ask: Construction Hazards and AsbestosWhat safeguards should apply to demolition, asbestos-containing materials, dust, noise, and construction-related emissions? The poll did not ask: Infrastructure, Transportation, and ParkingShould sewer systems, stormwater capacity, schools, transportation, and parking conditions be evaluated when substantial new development is proposed? The poll did not ask: Developer Profits and Public Benefits. Should the financial gains associated with redevelopment be accompanied by stronger requirements for permanently affordable housing or other public benefits? The poll did not ask: As-of-Right Development and Public OversightUnder an as-of-right framework, a project satisfying applicable requirements generally does not undergo the same discretionary approval process as one requiring special permission. The poll did not ask: Residents' ability to contest a compliant project's height, bulk, placement, or neighborhood impacts may therefore be limited. The poll did not ask: Should residents have stronger procedural protections or opportunities for review? The poll did not ask: How many people live in your home; are they co-renters or are they related. The poll did not ask questions germane to "filtering" (a key idea behind supply / demand approaches to housing costs. Would respondents be interested in leaving their current homes and neighborhoods for a new more luxurious and more expensive home (likely a condo) elsewhere. How much more would they be willing to spend for this unit? How much would they be able to pay per month for a new home. How much would they be willing to pay for rent. Would the property that they leave likely sell for less than the value of their existing one, allowing someone with less money to acquire it? The poll did not address the factors implied by problematic 48% of those who responded had read little or nothing about the ordinance (see below). The poll did not address the differential responses of the 23% of respondents who actually knew a lot about the upzoning. CONCLUSIONS:
The poll provides no direct evidence of public opinion on these important issues. In the end, only 20% Favor the Status Quo: What Should City Council Do?This brings us back to the finding that deserves far more attention. Only 20% of respondents favored keeping the ordinance unchanged. Thirty-two percent preferred targeted changes, and 37% favored broader changes, even if these slowed housing production. These findings should prompt City Council to examine which concerns residents want addressed and what revisions could respond to them. The survey also does not identify precisely which changes respondents favor. That is another reason why better polling is necessary. Rather than treating the 64% support figure as a mandate for maintaining the ordinance as written, the Council should examine the substantial interest in reform. It should also seek more information about the poll's methodology, including recruitment, weighting, and subgroup sample sizes. A more professionally done survey should ask directly about demolition, tenant displacement, environmental protection, affordability, infrastructure, developer incentives, and public review. Support for Housing Is Not the Same as Support for Every Development PolicyCambridge needs a serious discussion about how to provide additional housing while protecting existing residents, affordable homes, mature trees, and the environment. The recent poll offers useful information about general attitudes toward housing construction. But its findings are more complex than the single headline that 64% support the ordinance. The poll's limited description of the ordinance, its narrow framing of certain choices, and the absence of questions about important consequences of redevelopment constrain what can be concluded. Its methodology also warrants fuller public disclosure. Most important, nearly seven in ten respondents favored some kind of change to the ordinance. A citywide housing policy should not be judged only by how many buildings it permits. It should also be evaluated by whom it benefits, what it replaces, the people it may displace, and its environmental and neighborhood consequences. Cambridge residents deserve a fuller debate—and a more complete survey—before their views are reduced to a single percentage. Source and methodological note Cambridge Multifamily Housing Ordinance Poll, September 28–October 4, 2026. Weighted sample of 442 respondents; reported modeled margin of error of 4.9 percentage points. Percentages and question descriptions are drawn from Cambridge Multifamily Housing Ordinance Poll: Readable Transcription and Enlarged Subgroup Cross-Tabs, pages 1–20. The full methodology, recruitment procedures, weighting specifications, unweighted subgroup sizes, and details of questionnaire development have been requested from Embold Research. The methodological questions raised here are not findings of misconduct or evidence that any particular weighting procedure was improper.
0 Comments
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Location |
|